8 Signs Your Organization is Struggling with Shallow Work—and How to Fix It

Pedro Matriciano

In today's digital age, where multitasking and immediate responses are often praised, the true value of focused, uninterrupted work can easily be overshadowed. Yet, as Cal Newport articulates in his seminal research, "Shallow work keeps you busy; deep work makes you valuable." In this context, we need to identify the signs that indicate an organization is submerged in shallow work rather than fostering environments for deep work. Below are the eight key signs that your organization might be struggling with shallow work, along with practical solutions to correct course.

1. High Volume of Emails and Messaging Apps Notifications

The Sign
If your employees are constantly checking their emails or messaging apps, it's an indication that they are likely engaged in shallow work.

The Fix
Encourage specific time slots for checking emails and responding to messages. Make it a part of the company culture to not expect immediate responses unless it's truly urgent.

2. A Calendar Filled with Back-to-Back Meetings

The Sign
A schedule packed with meetings leaves little room for focused, uninterrupted work.

The Fix
Restrict the number of meetings and enforce a company-wide policy that requires a strong justification for any meeting that is set. Consider implementing a meeting-free day each week to enable deep work.

3. Multitasking is the Norm

The Sign
If multitasking is common in your organization, it's hard for employees to delve into tasks that require deep concentration and cognitive skills.

The Fix
Educate team members about the science behind multitasking and its productivity pitfalls. Encourage single-tasking and the use of tools that can help minimize distractions.

4. Lack of Clear Goals and Objectives

The Sign
Without clearly defined goals, employees may resort to busywork that has little impact on the bottom line.

The Fix
Regularly communicate the organization's objectives and how individual work aligns with these goals. This will give employees a framework to prioritize tasks that contribute to long-term success.

5. High Employee Turnover Rate

The Sign
A high turnover rate may indicate dissatisfaction among employees who are unable to find value in their work because they're caught in a cycle of shallow tasks.

The Fix
Incorporate deep work into employee development plans. Show team members that their growth and the complexity of their tasks will increase over time, leading to more satisfying roles.

6. A Culture that Celebrates Busyness over Productivity

The Sign
If employees are praised for simply being busy rather than being productive, it creates a culture of shallow work.

The Fix
Shift recognition towards the quality and impact of work done, rather than the number of hours put in. Develop KPIs that measure meaningful outcomes and celebrate those.

7. No Quiet Zones or Spaces for Focused Work

The Sign
The lack of designated areas for focused work can be a barrier to achieving deep work, leading employees to engage in more shallow tasks.

The Fix
Create quiet zones or rooms specifically designed for deep work. Make sure they are free from digital and human interruptions.

8. Immediate Availability is Expected

The Sign
If immediate responses to queries and issues are expected, it can create a toxic work environment where shallow work is the norm.

The Fix
Set guidelines around response times for emails and other forms of communication. Cultivate an organizational understanding that not everything is urgent.

Wrapping Up

Shifting from shallow to deep work isn't an overnight change; it requires ongoing commitment from the top to the bottom of the organization. However, by recognizing these signs and implementing their corresponding fixes, you can pave the way for a culture that values deep, meaningful work.

For those of you interested in diving deeper into how to create exceptional teams that are equipped for deep work, consider reading the asset titled "What Separates Good Teams from Exceptional Ones?" You can access it here. This resource will provide you with additional insights into creating a high-performing work environment that nurtures focused, valuable work over shallow busywork.

About the author

Pedro is the content manager of BookClub's Bookshelf Blog. With over a decade in EdTech, Pedro's become the go-to guy for transforming the best of books into engaging blog content. Not only does he have a knack for curating fantastic book lists that keep our readers hooked, but he also has the unique talent of bringing the essence of each book alive on our blog. Pedro might not be a writer by trade, and yes, but don't let that fool you. Having surfed the internet waves since the days before Google existed, he has an unparalleled eye for what makes content truly great. Join Pedro on the Bookshelf Blog as he continues to share book lists, insights, and treasures he finds along his journey.

Stay Up to Date

Your go-to resource for avid readers! Discover a wealth of information on
non-fiction business books aimed at boosting your professional development.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.